The ASA Technical Questions and Answers is a free service offered to all users, but primarily intended for engineers, architects, owners and anyone else who may be specifying the shotcrete process and/or has need for a possible answer to a technical question.
User agreement: The answers provided to submitted questions are intended for guidance in planning and executing shotcrete applications. This information is intended only for the use of individuals who are competent to evaluate the significance and limitations of its content and recommendations, and who will accept responsibility for the application of the material it contains. The American Shotcrete Association provides this information based on the best knowledge available to them and disclaims any and all responsibility for the information provided. The American Shotcrete Association will not be liable for any loss or damage arising therefrom.
If you are unable to find what you are looking for in the archive, then submit a new technical question.
RepairQ A circular concrete tank built in the 1980s is to be resurfaced due to cracks in the exterior shotcrete lining. It has been proposed that the existing surface will be hydroblasted. Is there a concern that the shotcrete may contain asbestos?
No, there is no reason to assume that the shotcrete would contain asbestos. Shotcrete linings typically contain sand and cement. Asbestos was commonly used for pipe insulation and high-temperature industrial uses and not for shotcrete.
RepairStructuralQ ACI 318-14 (Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete) requires post-installed expansion anchors to meet the testing criteria of ACI 355.2-07 (Qualification of Post-installed Mechanical Anchors in Concrete). ACI 355.2 specifies certain anchor testing and evaluation requirements to verify suitable anchor performance and to determine other aspects (such as failure mode) to use in conjunction with Chapter 17 of ACI 318 when designing the post-installed expansion anchors. Anchor testing is required largely to be performed by an independent agency and normally is conducted in normal weight and/or light weight concrete that meet pertinent ACI, ASTM and other requirements. Some post-installed expansion anchor manufacturers (like Hilti) have not had their anchors tested per ACI 355.2 in shotcrete type concrete, only tested in normal weight and light weight concrete. As such, these anchor manufacturers typically do not publish/offer any permitted load ratings, installation torques or other design and installation requirements for their expansion bolts when used in shotcrete. Instead, they recommend site testing to determine anchor performance or that the responsible design engineer can make an engineering judgment on anchor acceptability, as appropriate, if site testing is not performed. Do you have knowledge of any expansion bolt manufacturers that have tested their products is typical shotcrete? If yes to #1 above, do you know if the testing was done per ACI 355.2 requirements?
Shotcrete is a placement method for concrete. With proper equipment and placement techniques, concrete shotcreted in place will have strength, unit weight, permeability, and other hardened properties equivalent or superior to cast concrete consolidated by vibration. Due to delivering concrete material through relatively small diameter lines (1.5 to 2 in.) [38 to 51 mm] concrete mixtures for shotcrete placement typically limit the maximum coarse aggregate size to a nominal 3/8 to ½ in. (9.5 – 13 mm) size.
Thus, answering your specific questions:
- We are not aware of any expansion bolt manufacturers tests that used shotcrete placement of concrete for their test samples. However, tests on cast concrete should be equivalent with a given compressive strength and aggregate size/type in the concrete mixture.
- We expect that as answered in #1, that the tests run with ACI 355.2 requirements in cast concrete would have similar results when used with shotcrete placement of the concrete mixtures with similar hardened properties.
Also, note that ACI 318-19 directly includes shotcrete as a placement method for structural concrete.
RepairArchitecturalGeneralQ Can a gunite bridge surface be painted? And if so, what preparation/materials are recommended.
Yes, shotcrete is a placement method for concrete, so any coating appropriate for concrete would be applicable specify new concrete should be a certain age before applying their coating. Generally, the concrete surface should be clean and dry before coating. The surface texture provided on the shotcrete can affect the coating application. A hard, smooth steel trowel finish will tend to be quite slick, and the coating may not bond as well as a floated or sponge finish. A light abrasive blast may be considered to roughen the surface and give more bond. If using a gun or rodded finish for the shotcrete, the coating will generally require quite a bit more material to be able to fill the depressions in the surface.
RepairQ Can shotcrete be used to help seal a leaking pond? We have a 1.5 acre (6070 m²) pond that we are in the process of completing. We spread 90,000 lb (40,823 kg) of bentonite in, but the bentonite washed off the steep banks and now we are stuck with a half-full pond. Would shotcrete be a practical solution for our problem?
Properly designed shotcrete (both concrete materials and reinforcing are important in the design) placed by an experienced shotcrete contractor can certainly be used to provide a somewhat watertight lining for your pond that will be serviceable, durable, and require little to no maintenance for decades to come. We would suggest you consult with an engineer or shotcrete contractor experienced in this type of shotcrete work. You may use our online Buyers Guide to find an ASA corporate member consultant or contractor to assist you.
RepairQ Can shotcrete be used to repair a wall made of cement and fly ash? If so, should the wall be prepared for the shotcrete application?
Structurally sound concrete that contains up to 20% fly ash in the total cementitious materials should not present any problems for subsequent bonding of shotcrete. Concrete with fly ash contents up to 30% have been used in recent years without any reported problems with strength and bond. Although concrete mixtures with higher levels of fly ash (up to 55%) have been proposed, we don’t have direct experience with their bonding characteristics. We suspect it would be fine as long as the base concrete develops adequate compressive and tensile strength. This could be confirmed by a simple bond strength test of shotcrete on the concrete substrate in question.
The existing surface needs to be properly prepared, removing all soft or deteriorated material back to sound concrete. For extensive defects in the existing concrete, chipping hammers may be required. For removal of light surface carbonation or laitance, a strong, high-pressure water blast or sand/bead blasting may be adequate. Depending on the thickness of the shotcrete, reinforcing may be required in the overlay. Specific details of the repair are best developed by an engineer experienced in shotcrete repair.
RepairQ I am a civil engineer looking to use shotcrete in a culvert rehabilitation project. Due to flow constraints, we are forced to have a maximum wall thickness of 3 in. (76 mm). For the typical 96 in. (2438 mm) precast concrete culvert, the walls are approximately 9 in. (228 mm). What can I do to obtain a near similar product with only 3 in. (76 mm) of wall thickness? Can shotcrete be applied at higher compressive strengths, 10 psi (0.07 MPa), or is it better to use fiber-reinforced shotcrete? The intent of the retrofit is to at least obtain a 10-year service life to this temporary solution.
This is an engineering question, not an application question. Precast pipe is sized for multiple uses and services. Depending on this service (depth of cover or loads), creative reinforcing bar placement and higher compressive strengths can reduce the wall thickness significantly. For example, success has been realized using elliptical steel to reduce concrete section thickness. Fiber reinforcement is secondary reinforcing and is not a suitable replacement for reinforcing steel. Given the short life required of the culvert, and assuming fairly equal loading on the circumference, a 3 to 4 in. (76 to 101 mm) section with judiciously placed reinforcing bar, and silica fume (8 to 10% of cement for higher strength up to 10,000 psi (69 MPa)]) would be sufficient. The resulting culvert’s life would probably be much longer than 10 years. In the end, an engineering call should be made, but the material will perform.
RepairQ I am currently working on a project that involves repairing the concrete walls of a sanitary sewer interceptor structure and line pipe and was wondering if you had any reference information regarding shotcrete being used to repair similar items and how well it has held up. Any information you send will be greatly appreciated.
Shotcrete, both wet- and dry-mix, have been used to repair and reline sewer structures for many decades and has held up well as a lining or repair material. It is important to have the work done by a qualified shotcrete specialty contractor and to specify a durable concrete mixture design. The following are links to articles which may also be of interest to you:
RepairQ I am in the process of designing a 6″ shotcrete overlay for an existing wall that is approximately 1,250 square feet. The shotcrete subcontractor has proposed to use a dry-mix shotcrete. What are the advantages and disadvantages to the dry-mix process? The design includes dowels on 24″ centers and 4×4 W4xW4 wire mesh. Can the entire 6 inch thickness be placed at one or will it require a number of different lifts to build up to the 6 inch thickness?
The overlay can be placed successfully with either a dry-mix or wet-mix shotcrete process. The preference of the shotcrete subcontractor is likely related to his/her past experience and what they are best suited doing. The advantages of dry-mix process are beyond the scope of a simple answer. The process is well described in ACI 506R Guide to Shotcrete. The entire 6 inch thickness can be placed in one layer using the bench gunning technique. The number of vertical lifts would depend upon the height of the wall and the nature of the surface that the shotcrete is being placed against.
RepairQ I am interested in any information or suggestions you may have regarding practical working space requirements for shotcrete applications. Shotcrete is a common approach for sewer pipeline and storm-water culvert rehabilitation projects. My concern relates to the space requirements necessary to best ensure a quality installation—for pipelines, this boils down to the question: What is the smallest diameter pipe that can be used for this method? Technical specifications that I have come across call for a minimum of 3 ft (1 m) between the surface being covered and the application nozzle. To me, this means that pipes that are much smaller than 6 ft (1.8 m) would create some difficulty. Similarly, for applications between vertical walls, how much room does a nozzleman need between the wall receiving the shotcrete and the wall at his/her back? Are there robotic means or other methods in use that would allow shotcrete applications without a hands-on nozzleman? Are there any other workspace limitations or controls that should be considered when determining feasibility of shotcrete application methods?
In the case of installing a lining inside of an existing pipe, there are robotic methods available, such as spin lining, where the cementitious material is cast from a rotating head as the carrier is moved along the pipe. For pipe smaller than 42 in. (1067 mm) diameter, the spin lining is likely the best method.
For pipe larger than 42 in. (1067 mm) and up to 6 or 8 ft (1.8 or 2.4 m) diameter, either hand shotcrete nozzling or spin lining are applicable. For pipes much larger than 6 to 8 ft (1.8 to 2.4 m), hand nozzling is likely the best solution.
In the case of clearance between a wall to be shotcreted and an obstruction, 3 ft (1 m) is a good rule of thumb, but a qualified and experienced shotcrete contractor can use modified equipment to place quality shotcrete in tighter spaces. A recent article on shotcreting in confined spaces can be found here.RepairQ I am looking through Chapter 20 of ACI 350-06, “Code Requirements for Environmental Engineering Concrete Structures and Commentary,” and I don’t see any suggested methods for repair—only that the structure (or any repair) must meet specified criteria (strength, load testing, etc.) for serviceability. I am trying to find some reference allowing shotcrete to be used to reestablish the thickness of an existing structure that has inadequate cover over reinforcement. Can you provide any guidance?
The ACI 350 Code doesn’t really cover repair in detail because it is more about new environmental structures. Shotcrete is concrete; it provides excellent bond to properly prepared concrete substrates and it inherently creates a composite section with the existing concrete that acts monolithically. The supplemental shotcrete could be considered an additional layer of concrete that acts monolithically and thus provides the needed concrete cover. Reference-wise, you could refer to the article “Shotcrete Placed in Multiple Layers does NOT Create Cold Joints” in the Shotcrete magazine archive, as it discusses the bond issue between layers. There are research papers that discuss a 200 psi (1.4 MPa) bond shear stress is needed for a bonded concrete overlay to act monolithically, and that bond pulloff (tensile) test results should be multiplied by 2 or 3 to represent the bond shear capacity. Because we typically well exceed a 145 psi (1.0 MPa) tensile bond pulloff strength, properly applied shotcrete will easily exceed the 200 psi requirement for the bond to act monolithically.
An additional factor in providing additional cover with shotcrete is that shotcrete has very cement-rich paste, along with low permeability, and thus provides a better alkaline environment to combat corrosion of embedded reinforcement, so is effectively giving even better cover than normal form-and-pour concrete.