As you discovered, experience of the shotcrete contractor is key to a successful project. It takes an experienced and knowledgeable shotcrete team (the project manager, supervisor, pump or gun operator, nozzlemen, and finishers) to get a quality job. Answering your specific questions:
- Can this be done with either a dry or wet mix? Yes, either wet or dry mix will produce good results. You must be sure to properly prepare the substrate including chipping/bush hammering back to sound concrete, fully cleaning the surface and then bringing the surface to a saturated surface-dry condition (SSD).
- Do you need to bush a recessed area to accept a minimum amount of new material in lieu of a feather edge? Feather edging will create a very thin layer that would have more potential to spall when exposed to shrinkage or seasonal thermal movements. We recommend creating a square shoulder at least 0.75 in. (19.0 mm) deep to create an acceptable thickness of the patching layer.
- Is a wet mix acceptable to fill these areas given that the aggregate in it is generally up to 0.375 in. or so? With the dry-mix being primarily concrete sand and cement it would seem more practical. Wet-mix with a coarse aggregate can be shot in thin layers, but with a 0.375 in. coarse aggregate may require more finishing due to impact depressions of the aggregate in the shot surface. A dry-mix material without coarse aggregate may be easier to fill in the thin layers. Dry mix is typically less productive in volume placed per hour than wet mix, but in this relatively small-volume repair application, either process should be fine.
ACI 117 provides an excellent guide for tolerances for concrete structures. Although shotcrete is concrete, ACI 117 specifically excludes shotcrete because shotcrete’s unique method of placement permits a wider variety of applications and uses than that of form-and-pour concrete. Shotcrete can generally be finished to the tolerances required for the application. For example, lining a channel might not need close tolerance control, while an Olympic luge/sledding track or skateboard park may require very exacting tolerances. ACI 506.2-16, “Specification for Shotcrete,” in the Tolerances section (and the Mandatory checklist item) requires the specifier producing the contract documents to provide the tolerances required for the project. ACI 506R-16, “Guide to Shotcrete,” Section 3.8, Tolerances, provides a more descriptive commentary. Pertinent portions of that section include:
- Tolerances provide an indication of the finished product expected by the owner, but meeting tolerances may require additional effort and cost. Tolerances given by ACI 117.1R, for placement of reinforcing steel, cover over reinforcing steel, and overall alignment of cast-in-place structural members should be generally the same for shotcrete. Tolerances that require distinct values for shotcrete construction are cross-sectional dimensions, cover, and surface finish (or flatness). Therefore, specifying tolerances that can be consistently achieved are needed so that project expectations can be met at a reasonable cost.
- Specified tolerances should be based on use and function and can be the same as concrete, but are typically broader. Some finished surface tolerances may be waived to achieve proper coverage over existing reinforcement.
Although some shotcrete structures have been allowed greater tolerances than allowed for concrete, shotcrete structures can be built to the same degree of accuracy and tolerance as cast-in-place concrete.
You should review the entirety of Section 3.8, Tolerances, in ACI 506R-16 to get a complete description of tolerances for shotcrete placements.
The minimum strength for safety must be established by the designer based on the specific structural and geotechnical aspects of the project. The minimum strength value may also be influenced on whether using fiber-reinforced shotcrete or plain shotcrete. The early-age strength was tested with a Meyco Needle Penetrometer after creating a time (early) strength curve with minimum tests at 10 minutes and 30 minutes with Needle Penetrometer; then at 3 hours and 6 hours with Hilti Studs; then at 1, 7, and 28 days with cores. Thus, the curve was calibrated for the specific mixture and environmental conditions. It was also useful to identify when early strength (and potentially long-term strength) was lacking.
ACI 506.2-95, “Specification for Shotcrete,” is the deprecated version, and is no longer published (it isn’t readily available on the ACI website). Thus, the Tech Note along with the current ACI 506.2-13, “Specification for Shotcrete,” is the current industry standard for evaluating cores. An engineer may specify use of the outdated ACI 506.2-95; however, they are opening up their exposure because it isn’t the current standard. This is similar to the exposure if an engineer uses a much older version of ACI 318, and not the current one.
Generally, sand/cement in standard concrete mixtures starts breaking down around 400 to 500°F (200 to 260°C) because the portland cement starts to dehydrate. It loses strength with every phase and will have no strength after 1000°F (540°C). Putting it on brick depends on the shape of the brick surface. Uneven surfaces with holes will hold much better than flat brick. If the brick is flat, placing more than a couple of inches (±50 mm) may delaminate and fall off the wall without anchors of some sort. You could probably use a 2 x 2 in. (50 x 50 mm) or 3 x 3 in. (75 x 75 mm) mesh. In refractory, we consider low temperatures at 1700 to 1800°F (930 to 980°C). In the higher temperature refractory, we use calcium aluminate cement and “traprock,” which is a fine crushed limestone aggregate. The mixture ratios would be the same as a typical sand and cement gunning mixture. This is what traditionally has been for coal bunkers and coal dryers or any other sections in the 1700°F (930°C)-plus temperature range.
Shotcrete placement for a concrete wall gives the owner the advantages of concrete durability and the appearance of rock. Shotcrete has been used extensively for creating false rock faces for zoos, water parks, highways, and retaining walls. However, because shotcrete placement and carving to look like natural rock requires quite a bit of labor, the costs to do so may be more extensive than simply placing boulders.
Shotcrete is a placement method for concrete. So, standard concrete tests for shrinkage are applicable. You will find an article from Shotcrete magazine, “Shotcrete Testing—Who, Why, When, and How,” helpful. The specific section on drying shrinkage tests says:
“Drying shrinkage of the shotcrete can be tested using general provisions of ASTM C157. Because the shotcrete is shot into a large panel and not into the relatively small mold specified by ASTM for the shrinkage test beam, it is recommended that a beam approximately 11.25 in. (285 mm) in length be sawed from a test panel. As most shotcrete uses coarse aggregate less than 1 in. (25 mm), a 3 in. (75 mm) thick panel with a 3 in. (75 mm) wide cut should approximate the ASTM requirements. The A/E should specify in the contract documents drying shrinkage limits that are appropriate for the design of the structure.”
Shotcrete is a placement method for high-quality concrete. Here’s a link to an article of a rehabilitation of a concrete-supported lighthouse in the St. Lawrence Seaway (Pointe de la Prairie Lighthouse) that provides a lot of detail on an installation like yours, including saltwater exposure in a tidal zone. Additionally, this project also has regular freezing-and-thawing exposure (shotcrete.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/2014Sum_Sustainability.pdf).
Another project with tidal zone exposure involved repair of bridge pier pile caps on the East Coast of Florida. The article details the project parameters and testing conducted to verify the quality of the shotcrete placement (shotcrete.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/2012Win_White.pdf).
Shotcrete compressive strength should be tested using cores from test panels. Shotcrete cannot be shot into closed cylinder forms and be representative of the in-place shotcrete. ASTM C1140-11 and C1604-05(2012) provides the panel configuration and compression testing requirements. However, if using the wet-mix process for shotcreting and one wants to verify the compressive strength, air content, or temperature of ready mixed concrete materials as delivered, rather than as shotcreted in place, samples can be taken from the truck before pumping. These cylinders would follow ASTM C31-15 for making and curing concrete test specimens.
Shotcrete is a placement method for concrete. If the berm is composed of granular materials, one wouldn’t expect the shotcrete to actually bond to the soil. Rather, placing a thin shotcrete layer would create a uniform, relatively impermeable layer of concrete to prevent water from penetrating through and washing out the soil underneath. The emulsion may help to stabilize the soil to help withstand the pressure of shotcreting directly against the berm, but many similar soil stabilization projects will shotcrete directly onto the natural soils. Also, when considering using the emulsion, be aware that some oils may contain ingredients (like sulfur) that can attack the concrete over time. You should consult with an engineer or concrete materials specialist to ascertain whether the specific oil you want to use will have a long-term effect on the shotcreted layer.
