Most shotcrete slopes are placed without moisture barriers and are constructed to ensure that water pressure does not build up behind the slope and create hydrostatic pressure on the backside of the shotcrete. This is generally done with drainage material and weep holes or vents near the base of the shotcrete slope. Please bear in mind that shotcrete slope paving alone is not generally considered as a retaining wall. If shotcrete slope paving is to be used as a retaining structure, it is generally done in conjunction with soil nailing, tie backs, or some type of structural footing. If the shotcrete is intended to be used as a structural wall, a structural engineer must be consulted to be sure all structural issues are addressed.
How can I maintain a 2 in. (50 mm) thickness of shotcrete in a rock excavated tunnel?
There are many ways of maintaining the thickness of shotcrete. When placing shotcrete over a rough rock excavation, the thickness will vary with more material filling in the voids than covering the high points. Some methods of checking or maintaining the thickness are as follows: stabbing the plastic shotcrete with a depth gauge; preinstalling pins to the desired thickness; and using groundwires or shooting wires that would create an even plane over the length of the wires.
We are constructing a canopy for a mine entrance. We need to attach some type of wire mesh to the wood fillers to give the shotcrete some surface to bond to. What type of wire would be the best for this application? The mine canopy is self-supporting and the shotcrete is strictly to be used as a sealant.
AA typical wire mesh for such applications is 2 x 2 in. (51 x 51 mm) by 12 or 14 gauge; 3 x 3 in. (76 x 76 mm) by 11 gauge; or 4 x 4 in. (102 x 102 mm) by 10 gauge. It is important that the mesh be secured such that it does not move during the shotcrete placement. The mesh will tend to be pushed away from the back surface by the pressure of the shotcrete application.
We are currently designing a retaining wall, sloped at 1H:0.5V, 18 ft (5.5 m) high. We want to use shotcrete for this 12 in. (300 mm) thick structural wall. For strength requirements, we are able to use a 0.4 in. (10 mm) mesh; however, this does not satisfy for crack control requirements. For crack control, it is required that 1/2 in. (12 mm) individual reinforcing bars are used. Obviously, for cost and ease of construction, the mesh is the favorable choice of reinforcing. Is there a typical section for this type of application? Will shotcrete shrink less than placed concrete?
Each retaining wall needs to be engineered for the specific job conditions. It is fairly common, however, to see two layers of reinforcing bars in a wall of this thickness. In addition to reinforcing the wall, the steel would help support the shotcrete during placement. If drying shrinkage crack control is an issue, synthetic fibers may be added. Shrinkage in shotcrete mixtures may be higher than placed concrete with a 1 in. (25 mm) maximum-sized coarse aggregate due to smaller coarse aggregate size in shotcrete mixtures, higher fine aggregate content, and higher cement/cementitious material content. This may be partially offset by a slightly lower water-cementitious material ratio in a shotcrete mixture.
We are currently designing a retaining wall, sloped at 1H:0.5V, 5.5 high. We want to use shotcrete for this 12 inch (300mm) thick structural wall. For strength requirements, we are able to use a 10mm mesh, however this does not satisfy for crack control requirements. For crack control, it is required that we us 1/2 inch (12mm) individual rebars. Obviously for cost and ease of construction, the mesh is a favorable choice for reinforcing. Is there a typical section for this type of application? Will shotcrete shrink less than poured concrete?
Each retaining wall needs to be engineered for the specific job conditions. However it is fairly common to see two layers of reinforcing bars in a wall of this thickness. In addition to reinforcing the wall, the steel would help support the shotcrete during placement. If drying shrinkage crack control is an issue, synthetic fibers may be added. Shrinkage in shotcrete mixes may be higher than a poured concrete with a 1″ (25mm) maximum sized coarse aggregate content, and higher cement/cementitious material content. This may be partially offset by a slightly lower water/cementitious material ratio in a shotcrete mixture.
I am bidding a tunnel project and am uncertain about part of the specifications. Are specifications for shotcrete temperature different for the wet and dry processes? Are there separate requirements for the shotcrete, ambient, and surface temperatures? Can you refer me to industry standards?
The requirements for material temperatures are the same for both wet and dry shotcreting. Refer to Sections 8.7 and 8.8 of ACI 506R-90, “Guide to Shotcrete,” for recommended shotcrete temperatures during placement. Additional information is available in ACI 506.2-95, “Specification for Shotcrete,” in the sections on hot and cold weather shotcreting. Generally, concrete mixtures should be maintained at temperatures above 50 °F (10 °C) and below 100 °F (38 °C). Ambient temperatures should be maintained in a similar range.
Regarding surface temperatures, concrete should never be placed on a frozen substrate. Practical experience in Canadian mines has lead to a suggested minimum temperature of 40 °F (4 °C) for the rock receiving the shotcrete. Without special measures, cold temperatures will cause the shotcrete to set more slowly and result in slower strength development. Remember that in thin sections, the shotcrete will lose its heat more quickly in cold conditions.
I’m looking for information as to the thickness design of shotcrete for ditch slope lining purposes. Can you direct me?
Typically, the thickness is a minimum of 3 inches and slope lining in the 6 to 8 inch range is often installed. The reinforcing is also variable with the lightest sections with no reinforcing or a low dosage of polyfibers or light welded wire fabric and the heavier sections with rebar. Basically, a lot of different designs can be used. We are not aware of any widely used standards.
Do you have any publications on shotcrete curing, specifically in tunneling? How is shotcrete cured in tunnel constructions with the temperature and moisture problems?
All concrete must be cured to ensure full and proper hydration of cementitious components control of shrinkage. Shotcrete is concrete placed pneumatically, therefore must be cured, as all concrete must be. The tunnel environment presents positive and negative conditions. The humidity in an underground space is generally high in humidity and constant in a moderate to cool temperature. Both conducive to slow egress of moisture from the concrete and “natural” curing. The negative in tunnel construction is ventilation air which is generally of high volume and high speed, which tends to dry the surface and “pull” important moisture out of the sprayed concrete. Most tunnels can tolerate extra water in the work space, therefore misting or spraying water onto the concrete surfaces, especially overhead, is the most practical method of curing. Sprayed on liquid membranes are effective as long as their interference with bonding of additional layers of concrete, sprayed or cast, is not an issue. Recommended reading: “Understanding and Controlling Shrinkage and Cracking in Shotcrete” by D.R. Morgan and C.Chan, published in the ASA Shotcrete magazine.
I would like to get expert opinions regarding a proposal. I am reviewing from a contractor to replace precast concrete wall panels with shotcrete wall. The wall acts as a retaining wall and the precast panels were specified to span between the soldier piles (with tiebacks), driven and anchored into the rock at a spacing of 10 feet. Shotcrete walls over 3-inch wood lagging have been proposed to replace the precast panels and they have been designed exactly the same way as reinforced concrete walls. Using ACI Code working strength design for 4000 psi concrete, and fs= 24000 psi steel, the reinforcing in the shotcrete walls have been determined using value of a = 1.76 . ( As= M / 1.76. d ) I do not feel comfortable accepting the same equations and numbers for a shotcrete wall as for a cast-in-place or precast concrete wall with all the quality controls and rigid specifications per ACI 318 Code concerning mixing, formwork, placement, vibration and curing. Could you please provide an expert opinion on the matter? What would be the reasonable values of coefficient to determine the reinforcing in shotcrete walls?
We often use shotcrete in lieu of cast in place concrete without using different design factors. Shotcrete is simply a method of placing concrete. Properly designed and constructed, the same reinforcing steel used for cast-in-place concrete or precast concrete should be able to be used with shotcrete constructed retaining walls. The only differences would be in the reinforcing detailing, in that the rebars should be tied in a configuration that makes them suitable for proper encapsulation with shotcrete. Avoid bundled bars or other conditions not conducive to proper shotcrete encapsulation. See “ACI 506R-90 Guide to Shotcrete” for guidance, except that it is possible to use much larger diameter bars than indicated in that document, as has been described in several articles. (See for example the article by James Warner on “Dealing with Reinforcing” in the Winter 2001 of Shotcrete magazine.)
I am currently involved in the design of a large retaining wall for a job in Boston. One option under consideration is the use of soil nails with shotcrete lagging. The design anticipates a 100-year service life. What can I tell my client to realistically expect from the shotcrete option? Is shotcrete durable in the freezing-and-thawing conditions in this area? What is the best way to improve the longevity of the product?
The simplest way to clarify things is to advise your client that shotcrete is not a product but a process. Shotcreting is a process of installing concrete at a high velocity. Because the concrete is installed at a high velocity, it will have a higher density than conventional concrete in most cases. The increased density will provide reduced permeability and higher durability.
A shotcrete mixture can be designed and proportioned to meet virtually any job requirement. In this case, air entrainment must be specified. Whenever any concrete mixture (shotcrete mixtures included) will be exposed to freezing and thawing while critically saturated, air entrainment must be part of the mixture. The amount of air entrainment required depends on the maximum size of the coarse aggregate used. In general, for a mixture with a maximum-sized coarse aggregate of 3/8 in. (10 mm), the air content should be about 8% as-batched for a severe exposure condition.
Another key to longevity is reduction of permeability. As a mixture becomes denser, the transmission of fluids through the mixture becomes more difficult. This is especially critical when trying to protect reinforcing steel. When chloride ions and oxygen reach reinforcing steel, corrosion is initiated. Increasing the density by using products like silica fume, slag cement, and fly ash dramatically decreases permeability.
Discuss the curing and protection plan with the contractor prior to the start of shotcreting. Failure to cure and protect properly is the most common reason for poor concrete or shotcrete performance.
Another often overlooked element in obtaining an extended type of service life is maintenance of the concrete structure. By periodically cleaning the concrete and applying an appropriate surface sealer, materials that may lead to deterioration are removed from the surface and not allowed to penetrate the pore structure of the concrete.