SHOTCRETE VS FIRE AND WATER REPLACEMENT OF FLUME 4/5/6 AND 30

On August 14, 2021, the Caldor Fire started in Northern California near Pollock Pines, CA. The fire ended up consuming almost 222,000 acres (90,000 hectares) and seriously threatened South Lake Tahoe. Besides the over 1000 structures that were lost, the fire also burned along a major portion of the El Dorado Irrigation District’s Canal (EID) which provides drinking and irrigation water to numerous communities throughout the area

SHOTCRETE AT MT PLEASANT STATION

Multi-million dollar underground stations are currently under construction on Metro and LRT lines in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Traditionally, the thick, heavily reinforced structural concrete station walls have been constructed using the conventional form-and-pour concrete construction method. This construction method, while widely used, is not without its challenges.

Many of the underground station sites are in congested urban areas with limited spaces for laydown of concrete formwork, and crane access time for handling and installation of formwork is often on a critical path for completion of station construction.

HIGHLINE GARIBALDI SPRINGS ROCKSCAPE RETAINING WALL

This retaining wall was contracted for a new townhouse development project in Squamish, BC, Canada. Vancouver Shotcrete & Shoring Inc. has serviced many municipalities and private companies over the past 30 years in the fields of shotcrete shoring, pools, and custom rockscapes.

The shotcrete retaining wall was designed to be anchored by Titan 40 self-drilling anchors with a test load capacity of 52,000 lbs (24,000 kg) each, spaced every 6 ft (2 m) on center. The temporary 4 in. (100 mm) shotcrete was reinforced with 4 x 4 x 1 in. (100 x 100 x 25 mm) welded wire mesh, with a 0.8 in. (20 mm) continuous whaler lining to span the load between each anchor. The engineer specified a 5800 psi (40 MPa) shotcrete mix for this purpose.

I have a project with a segmental retaining wall. The project is located in Maryland. The CMUs of the retaining wall have significantly deteriorated in several areas. The geo-grid fabric appears to be in good condition in the areas where it could be observed. I suspect the deterioration is caused by saltwater runoff during snow events combined with the freeze/thaw cycles. There are some localized areas where the masonry units have completely disintegrated. The largest area being approximately 4 ft2 (0.37 m2). Is it feasible to remove the deteriorated masonry material, down to a sound surface, and shotcrete the face to restore (or exceed) the structural integrity of masonry units? If so, will this restore the structural integrity of the segmental retaining wall?

Shotcrete is routinely used for the repair of deteriorated concrete masonry and brick. Shotcrete should easily have a minimum compressive strength of 4000 psi (28 MPa) when properly shot and cured. According to the National Concrete Masonry Association, current CMU units have a minimum 2000 psi (14 MPa) compressive strength. Older CMU had a lower 1500 psi (10 MPa) minimum. Thus, the shotcrete placement will be significantly stronger and less permeable than the in-place CMU. This should give the wall better resistance to saltwater and freeze-thaw exposures thus extending useful life.

Depending on the depth of the new shotcrete placement, you may consider mechanically tying the shotcreted layer back to the sound CMU with epoxy or mechanically embedded anchors or j-bolts. Thicker sections may also benefit from the use of a steel wire mesh or fibers.

When shooting onto existing CMU sections, the surface must be properly prepared and then shotcreted with proper shotcrete materials, equipment, and placement techniques. Shotcrete placed onto an existing CMU surface will provide an excellent bond IF the following conditions are met:

  • Make sure the surface is roughened and clean.
  • The amplitude of roughness should be +/- 1/8th in. (3 mm) or more.
  • A high-pressure water blaster (5000 psi [34 MPa] or more) or abrasive blasting can help to roughen and clean the surface.
  • Bring the CMU surface to a saturated surface dry (SSD) condition. This means the surface feels damp, but water is not picked up on a hand.
  • Make sure the shotcrete placement is properly executed with high-velocity placement and quality materials.
  • The shotcrete should have a minimum 28-day compressive strength of 4000 psi (28 MPa).
  • Be sure the shotcrete contractor is using an air compressor able to produce at least 185 CFM (5.2m3/min) for wet-mix and 375 CFM (10.6 m3/min) for dry-mix (gunite) of air flow at 100 to 120 psi (0.7 to 0.8 MPa).
  • Use of an ACI-certified shotcrete nozzleman is recommended.
  • No bonding agent should be used. It will interfere with the natural bonding characteristics of shotcrete placement.

Finally, without details on the loading conditions, and structural details of the original construction, we cannot comment on the structural integrity of the repaired wall. You should contact a professional engineer experienced in concrete repair to evaluate the structural integrity of the wall when repaired.

#1 – Compressive (Strength) Values of Pool Shotcrete

Download

#2 – Definitions of Key Shotcrete Terminology

Download

#3 – Sustainability of Shotcrete in the Pool Industry

Download

#4 – Watertight Shotcrete for Swimming Pools

Download

#5 – Monolithic Shotcrete for Swimming Pools (No Cold Joints)

Download

#6 – Forming and Substrates in Pool Shotcrete

Download

#7 – Curing of Shotcrete for Swimming Pools

Download

#1 – Spraying Shotcrete Overhead in Underground Applications

Download

#2 – Spraying Shotcrete on Synthetic Sheet Waterproofing Membranes

Download

#3 – Encapsulation of Reinforcement in Tunnel Shotcrete Final Linings

Download

Filters

ASA Outstanding Shotcrete Awards Program

The ASA Outstanding Shotcrete Project Awards Program exists to recognize excellence and innovation on projects in which the application of shotcrete has played a significant role.

ASA’s Annual Outstanding Shotcrete Project Awards Program provides an exciting real-world demonstration of the exceptional advantages of placing concrete via the shotcrete process. Many sustainability advantages are also inherent in the shotcrete process and play a significant role in winning projects as well as the project owner’s ultimate decision to use shotcrete as the method of concrete placement. Projects must be completed between January 1, 2022, through September 1, 2024, and can be submitted in the following areas: Architecture │ New Construction, Infrastructure, International Projects, Pool & Recreational, Rehabilitation & Repair, and Underground.

To assist in your submission, we have provided submission resources to inform you of the submission guidelines, a list of questions, and a copy of the owner release form. Please email any questions to [email protected].

Award Archive

2025 – Twenty First Annual Outstanding Shotcrete Project Awardees

Outstanding Architecture

Fresno Chaffee Zoo: Kingdoms of Asia | Fresno, CA

Project Name:
Fresno Chaffee Zoo: Kingdoms of Asia

Location:
Fresno, CA

Shotcrete Contractor:
COST of Wisconsin*

Architect/Engineer:
CLR Design / Patrell Engineering

Material Supplier/Manufacturer:
Builders Concrete Inc. & Outback Concrete

Equipment Manufacturer:
REED Shotcrete Equipment*

General Contractor:
Bernards Bros

Project Owner:
Fresno Chaffee Zoo

More

New Construction Project

Point Grey Shoreline Stability | Vancouver, BC, Canada

Project Name:
Point Grey Shoreline Stability

Location:
Vancouver, BC, Canada

Shotcrete Contractor:
Ocean Rock Art LTD*

Architect/Engineer:
Paul Sangha Creative

Material Supplier/Manufacturer:
Heidelburg Materials

Equipment Manufacturer:
Putzmeister*

General Contractor:
GWilson Construction

Project Owner:
Claire and Jaime Wright

More

Outstanding Infrastructure Project

Humber College Station | Toronto, ON, Canada

Project Name:
Humber College Station

Location:
Toronto, ON, Canada

Shotcrete Contractor:
Consolidated Shotcrete Inc.*

Architect/Engineer:
Arup

Material Supplier/Manufacturer:
Dufferin Concrete

Equipment Manufacturer:
Western Shotcrete Equipment*

General Contractor:
Mosaic Transit Group Joint Venture (Aecon Infrastructure and Management Inc., Dragados Canada Inc., Dufferin Construction Company)

Project Owner:
Metrolinx

More

Outstanding International Project

National Route N2 Slope Stabilization | Eastern Cape, South Africa

Project Name:
National Route N2 Slope Stabilization

Location:
Eastern Cape, South Africa

Shotcrete Contractor:
Zolula (Pty) Ltd*

Architect/Engineer:
Bosch Projects / AGES-Group

Material Supplier/Manufacturer:
WBHO Construction

Equipment Manufacturer:
Putzmeister*

General Contractor:
WBHO Construction

Project Owner:
South African National Roads Agency SOC Ltd

More

Outstanding Pool & Recreational Project

Southern Living Pools | Horseshoe Bay, TX

Project Name:
Southern Living Pools

Location:
Horseshoe Bay, TX

Shotcrete Contractor:
Texan Concrete Construction Solutions, LLC dba – Texan Gunite*

Architect/Engineer:
Smith Engineering – Austin, TX

Material Supplier/Manufacturer:
Texan Concrete Construction Solutions, LLC dba – Texan Gunite*

Equipment Manufacturer:
Putzmeister America*

General Contractor:
Jeff Jackson Homes

Project Owner:
Southern Living Pools

More

Outstanding Rehabilitation & Repair Project

Abitibi Canyon Z7 Dam Rehabilitation | Abitibi Canyon, ON, Canada

Project Name:
Abitibi Canyon Z7 Dam Rehabilitation

Location:
Abitibi Canyon, ON, Canada

Shotcrete Contractor:
SWATcrete*

Architect/Engineer:
Atkins Realis

Material Supplier/Manufacturer:
L. Fournier & Fils Inc*

Equipment Manufacturer:
SWATcrete* (Customized Aliva 252)

General Contractor:
PETER KIEWIT SONS ULC

Project Owner:
Ontario Power Generation

More

Outstanding Underground Project

NYC Grand Central Station New Passageway | New York City, NY

Project Name:
NYC Grand Central Station New Passageway

Location:
New York City, NY

Shotcrete Contractor:
Patriot Shotcrete*

Architect/Engineer:
STV Incorporated

Material Supplier/Manufacturer:
Tec-Crete Transit Mix

General Contractor:
Skanska USA Civil Northeast

Project Owner:
Metropolitan Transit Authority

More

Honorable Mention Project

Pompeys Pillar National Monument Stabilize | Pompeys Pillar, MT

Project Name:
Pompeys Pillar National Monument Stabilize

Location:
Pompeys Pillar, MT

Shotcrete Contractor:
Shotcrete Montana LLC*

Architect/Engineer:
Bureau of Land Management- MT State OFC

Material Supplier/Manufacturer:
The Quikrete Companies*

Equipment Manufacturer:
REED Shotcrete Equipment*

General Contractor:
TripTych Construction LLC

Project Owner:
Bureau of Land Management – MT State OFC

More

Honorable Mention Project

Business in the Front, Party in the Back | Raleigh, NC

Project Name:
Business in the Front, Party in the Back

Location:
Raleigh, NC

Shotcrete Contractor:
Revolution Gunite*

Architect/Engineer:
Waterforge, Inc

Material Supplier/Manufacturer:
Revolution Gunite*

Project Owner:
Jiten Patel

Pool Contractor:
Raleigh Pools

More

Honorable Mention Project

North America’s Tallest Retained Façade | Toronto, ON, Canada

Project Name:
North America’s Tallest Retained Façade

Location:
Toronto, ON, Canada

Shotcrete Contractor:
Green Infrastructure Partners Inc.*

Architect/Engineer:
Grounded Engineering

Material Supplier/Manufacturer:
Canadian Building Materials

General Contractor:
EllisDon Residential

Project Owner:
481 Uni Investments Inc

More

Mapei’s London Underground Bank Station’s Capacity Upgrade

Deep in the heart of London’s financial centre, work has been continuing to make one of the world’s largest stations safer and easier for passengers to use. Finding your way around the existing labyrinth of tunnels, connecting five London underground lines, is a task worthy of the most experienced navigator.