Shotcrete is a placement method for concrete. If the berm is composed of granular materials, one wouldn’t expect the shotcrete to actually bond to the soil. Rather, placing a thin shotcrete layer would create a uniform, relatively impermeable layer of concrete to prevent water from penetrating through and washing out the soil underneath. The emulsion may help to stabilize the soil to help withstand the pressure of shotcreting directly against the berm, but many similar soil stabilization projects will shotcrete directly onto the natural soils. Also, when considering using the emulsion, be aware that some oils may contain ingredients (like sulfur) that can attack the concrete over time. You should consult with an engineer or concrete materials specialist to ascertain whether the specific oil you want to use will have a long-term effect on the shotcreted layer.
We are building an area of a park that is on an existing pier in Brooklyn, NY. We are researching using shotcrete to form contours on certain areas. Weighting of the pier is an issue. Our question is, can lightweight concrete, or cellular concrete, be used in shotcrete? If so, what are the weights?
Shotcrete is a placement method for concrete. Lightweight concrete usually ranges from 90 to 115 lb/ft3 (1400 to 1800 kg/m3). In wet-mix shotcreting, lightweight concrete should use presoaked aggregate to make the mixture pumpable. When it’s pumpable, as with conventional concrete mixtures, it is then accelerated to a high velocity by air at the nozzle and projected onto the surface. Lightweight aggregates can also be used directly in dry-mix, and there you don’t need to worry about pumpability because the dry materials are conveyed through the delivery hose. Water is added at the nozzle.
Here’s the specific reference on lightweight from ACI 506R-16, “Guide to Shotcrete”:
2.1.3.2 Lightweight aggregates—Lightweight aggregates should conform to ASTM C330/C330M if used in shotcrete. The aggregate should meet one of the gradations shown in Table 1.1.1. Wet-mix shotcrete with lightweight aggregate is seldom used and is difficult to pump because the aggregate absorbs water, which reduces the consistency of the mixture. Presaturating the lightweight aggregate before batching improves pumpability. Lightweight aggregate mixtures have been shot for wall and floor construction. Shotcrete is frequently employed for fireproofing structural steel members using lightweight aggregates in the mixture.
We suspect that cellular concrete cannot be shot because it uses injection of a pre-formed foam into a cement slurry and is highly fluid. That would preclude any stacking of material to make a vertical surface, and would instead just be pumped in place like a high slump concrete.
We have a backwash tank on a waste water treatment plant which is made by a secant wall. The lower area for this structure will receive a shotcrete liner approximately 12 ft (3.7 m) tall on average, the interior perimeter of the structure includes 104 lineal ft (32 m) of unreinforced and 440 ft (134 m) reinforced sections which are a 12 in (300 mm) minimum thickness. The drawings call for vertical control joints with waterstop approximately every 30 ft (9 m). We don’t believe the control joints are necessary and could achieve the same desired performance with one monolithic installation of the shotcrete. Are the control joints really necessary when you are installing the shotcrete against a solid secant wall which does not contain any control joints?
By control joints, we assume you mean contraction joints. Shotcrete is a placement method for concrete. All normal concrete experiences drying shrinkage that creates a volume change in the hardened concrete. Though shotcrete has a lower w/cm than most form and pour concrete, it will still undergo shrinkage. In being shot on an existing concrete wall the shotcrete liner will be restrained by the bond to the substrate and the restraint of the horizontal volume change from shrinkage can create internal tensile stresses in the concrete. This is likely the reason the designer has specified contraction joints in the section. 30 ft (9 m) spacing between joints is common in new construction of concrete tanks. The question becomes whether the bond of the shotcrete to the existing substrate is high enough to restrain the volume change and prevent cracking along the hundreds of lineal feet of wall you will be lining. The thickness of the lining, the type and duration of curing, the concrete mix design, the strength of the concrete, the strength of the substrate, the quality of shotcrete application, proper surface preparation and exposure to seasonal temperature changes will impact the effect of the volume change of the lining. With the many variables we’ve pointed out you can see there isn’t a clear answer that covers all situations. We recommend you discuss your opinion with the designer or consult with a professional engineer experienced in shotcrete repairs to fully evaluate the specific structural sections you’re shotcreting.
Our company has been working on the design of a concrete pond for winery wastewater and the contractor proposed to replace the concrete liner with a geomembrane (canal 3) covered by shotcrete. Have you seen cases of this application being successful for wastewater holding? As an alternative we are considering applying the shotcrete over a clay liner. Are there any concerns or recommendations for this approach?
Shotcrete is a placement method for concrete. Shotcrete has been successfully used for over 70 years in thousands of industrial wastewater treatment/storage tanks, as well as replacement lining of sewers and manholes. Thus, exposure of the shotcreted pond to wastewater should be as good or likely even better than the original cast concrete liner. Long term durability of the shotcreted section will be dependent on the concrete mixture design. Many contractors use supplemental cementitious materials (SCMs) like silica fume or fly ash to improve the pumping or shooting characteristics of the mix. These SCMs also help to reduce permeability, increase strength, and thus make the concrete more durable. Fly ash also has the benefit of adding some sulfate resistance that would be beneficial in wastewater exposure conditions. Shotcrete is often shot on geomembranes or directly on the subgrade soils if they are stable enough to hold the impact, and weight of the shotcrete.
I am currently involved with the design of an unreinforced masonry building retrofit. Could you point me toward resources concerning the seismic behavior of a reinforced shotcrete masonry wall? I am interested in learning more about the force (shear) transfer between the masonry/shotcrete interfaces.
Shotcrete is a placement method for concrete. Thus, seismic design for concrete is applicable to shotcrete placement. Here’s a link to an article in the Winter 2009 issue of Shotcrete magazine, titled “Seismic Retrofit of Historic Wing Sang Building,” that details the seismic retrofit of a brick building in Vancouver, BC, Canada: https://shotcrete.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/2009Win_SCM01pg08-12.pdf.
A second article from 1999, “Seismic Reinforcing of Masonry Walls with Shotcrete,” also gives some input on the design: https://shotcrete.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/1999Fal_Snow.pdf. In general, the structural engineer must evaluate the condition of the existing masonry structure and determine whether the added shotcrete sections will be supplementing the existing capacity or providing the full resistance to seismic loads.
Why is shotcrete not applied to general housing? It could be applied against outer insulation reinforced panels, forming both pillars and walls at the same time. Higher cost of shotcrete should be more than compensated by much shorter time and lower need of cranes.
Shotcrete has been used for residential concrete construction, often for domed or other curved shapes. It has also been used to provide a structural skin over internal insulation panels in more rectangular layouts. Since shotcrete is concrete projected at high speed (between 60 and 80 mph [97 to 129 km/h]) many insulation products do not withstand the impact and abrasion associated with shotcrete impact. In many cases when shooting over an insulating foam panel that cannot withstand the high velocity impact, shotcrete isn’t used, but a low-velocity plaster/grout mix is spray applied over the insulation. Here’s a link to the PCA website with a page on residential housing using a foam inner panel: https://www.cement.org/think-harder-concrete-/homes/building-systems/shotcrete. You can also find similar system information doing a web search for “shotcrete foam panel.”
We have an existing cut slope approximately 328 ft (100 m) high (3:1 vertical:horizontal) with cut benches and need to apply shotcrete onto the slope surface at a height of approximately 230 ft (70 m) from the road level. Is it possible to reasonably transfer and apply shotcrete mixture at such a height from the road level? What type of transfer hoses and equipment is preferable? Is dry-mix or wet-mix shotcrete preferable?
Yes, either dry-mix or wet-mix process can and have been used at this height. Because either process can be used in these conditions, you should use an experienced shotcrete contractor who will pick the best method based on their firm’s shotcrete capabilities. Factors such as the shotcrete contractor’s specific shotcrete equipment, material availability, site constraints, remoteness of the location, and crew experience will influence their choice.
We have 18 ft high, 12 in. thick (5.5 m high, 205 mm thick) walls to shotcrete and need horizontal cold joints to place the shotcrete in three pours (three height sections). How do we create the joint?
Shotcrete is routinely used in creating retaining walls or soil-nailed walls in this fashion. Designers and inspectors often confuse placement of multiple layers of shotcrete in building out a section with cold joints experienced in cast-in-place concrete construction. Unlike cast-in-place concrete, shotcrete provides thorough consolidation and densification by high-velocity impact of fresh concrete material on the receiving surface. The high-velocity impact of shotcrete on a hardened, previous shot layer (or existing concrete surface) provides a strong abrasive blast to open up the surface, and then provides an immediate exposure of that hardened surface to fresh cement paste. As a result, shotcrete exhibits excellent bond to concrete and previously shot surfaces. Thus, the structural action between the sections acts as a monolithic section without any weakened planes.
In shotcrete construction, surface preparation between layers to provide full bond is important. ACI 506.2-13, “Specification for Shotcrete,” specifically addresses this in the requirements of Section 3.4.2.1 and 3.4.2.2 that require:
3.4.2.1 When applying more than one layer of shotcrete, use a cutting rod, brush with a stiff bristle, or other suitable equipment to remove all loose material, overspray, laitance, or other material that may compromise the bond of the subsequent layer of shotcrete. Conduct removal immediately after shotcrete reaches initial set.
3.4.2.2 Allow shotcrete to stiffen sufficiently before applying subsequent layers. If shotcrete has hardened, clean the surface of all loose material, laitance, overspray, or other material that may compromise the bond of subsequent layers. Bring the surface to a saturated surface-dry condition at the time of application of the next layer of shotcrete.
An experienced shotcrete contractor should routinely provide proper surface preparation between shotcreted sections, and use skilled crews with ACI certified nozzlemen to place and cure the shotcrete placements.
We are planning on placing shotcrete over rock face and are concerned about water seeping out of the rock and forming ice behind the shotcrete. Could you please offer some insight?
Shotcrete is a functionally impermeable material when properly designed and placed. Thus, if water accumulates between the rock substrate and shotcrete, depending on temperatures and thickness of the shotcrete, it may freeze. As with all concrete, shotcrete material can be air-entrained to enhance resistance to freezing-and-thawing exposure. You should consult with an experienced engineer to determine whether the type of rock, geometry of the sections, and anchoring of the shotcrete (such as with soil nails or rock bolts), along with the bond of shotcrete to the rock, will provide the desired performance.
We are considering sealing off the openings of some existing water tunnels by constructing reinforced concrete walls within the openings. One wall, for instance, is 9.25 ft wide by 12 ft high (3 x 4 m) and is to be 22 in. (559 mm) thick. Other walls will be in the range of 18 to 26 in. (457 to 660 mm) thick. What are the limits as to the maximum thickness/size wall that shotcrete can be used to construct? Also, I noticed that in the latest revision of ACI 506R-05 that the previous recommended limits on the reinforcing bar size have been removed. I believe in the past, the reinforcing bars were limited to the smaller-size bars to reduce the development of sand pockets behind the bars. Is there a recommended limit on the size bars that can be used? Perhaps it was in the ACI standard but I just overlooked it.
Experienced shotcrete contractors with qualified crews have often shot structural concrete sections 24 to 30 in. (610 to 762 mm) thick with reinforcing bars up to No. 11 in size. There is no real limit to how thick you can build a shotcrete “wall.” Though earlier versions of ACI 506R, “Guide to Shotcrete,” did recommend limiting reinforcing bars sizes, modern equipment, concrete mixtures, and shooting techniques have proven that large-diameter steel reinforcing bars can be properly encased on a routine basis by experienced shotcrete crews. Thus, ACI 506R was updated to reflect the successful industry practice.