The application of shotcrete can be done successfully with either method. The dry-mix shotcrete process tends to be more favorable for lower volume placements. It is also a more flexible method, allowing for more frequent relocations of equipment. Equipment is more easily cleaned at the end of the placement. The nozzleman must exercise great care in adding the necessary amount of water while shooting.
The wet-mix shotcrete method is more favorable for larger volume placements. Rebound is substantially less than in the dry-mix shotcrete process. The nozzleman does not have to be concerned with controlling the water addition. This method is less efficient when there is a requirement for frequently starting and stopping placements. The wet shotcrete mixture has a limited “pot-life.”
Remember, shotcrete is not a special product. It is a method of placing concrete. All the recommended practices for concrete placed by any other method, such as curing and protection, also apply to shotcrete.
See ACI 506R, Sec. 1.7 (ACI document). Typical shrinkage varies in the range of 0.06 to 0.10 percent after 28 days drying. It is typically slightly higher than similar strength concrete, mostly due to less and/or smaller coarse aggregate in the shotcrete mix.
The ACI 506R-90 Guide to Shotcrete, Section 5.4.2 is the publication you are looking for. Amongst other things it states: “If the design allows, lapping of the reinforcing splices should be avoided. Lapped bars should be spaced apart at least three times the diameter of the largest bar at the splice”. If laps are not permitted by the design, then it is best to lap the bars one on top of the other (relative to the shooting orientation), rather than side-by-side, to facilitates proper encapsulation with shotcrete.
There are many textures that can be applied to the finish surface of the shotcrete. The least expensive is the natural nozzle finish which is rough and tends to absorb light as opposed to reflecting light and standing out. On the other extreme is carved and stained simulated rock as found in zoos and amusement parks. Stamping or rolling also creates a great finish. The broom finish is also very common. Color and textures are options and the owner or designer needs to decide on the value and effect he/she is looking for. Whatever finish, texture, pattern, color, stain, lump, bump, or crease that can be applied to concrete also applies here.
Basically, shotcrete is a method of placing concrete that does not require forms. As a matter of fact, shotcrete requires the concrete mix to be proper every time. With formed concrete walls, the ready mixed concrete going in can be substandard and still appear to be okay. Shotcrete also provides a more dense concrete less susceptible to water penetration. The most glaring difference will be the quality of the materials used. Most poured walls are designed for a compressive strength of 2500 to 3000 psi. Typically they are placed with a water/cementitious material ratio of 0.60 and higher. Curing is almost unknown in the poured wall sector. Protection only occurs in the coldest weather. By the very nature of the process, shotcrete will have a much lower w/cm ratio. This will produce a wall with higher compressive strength and have the attributes of lower w/cm ratio concrete, i.e. reduced permeability, less shrinkage, increased durability. With proper curing and protection, the shotcrete mixture will produce significantly better long-term performance. The shotcrete process should allow for easier addition of insulation to the walls as well. This is especially important if the basement is to be used for more than just storage.
Thicknesses depend on the structure and surface (surface prep is the key to proper bonding of shotcrete) the shotcrete is being applied to. Depending on the application 1/4 flash coat to 1 inch thickness can be the minimum. As far as shotcrete up to the steel windows, you have to consider that cracking may occur off of each corner. This can be minimized by adding additional reinforcement at those locations. It is common to tool in a joint around the windows so that we could apply a caulk later. The caulking will assure a waterproof seal between the window and the concrete during temperature changes that may create some expansion and contraction. You do not have to depend on the trim work to create the weather and water tight seal the architect requires.
Temporary lagging of shotcrete must meet some standard as it is the shoring holding back the earth. If reinforcing is used in the design of the temporary shoring it must be fully encapsulated to provide the design strength of the lagging as specified in the design. A temporary structure may have a low safety factor but the strength of the rebar and shotcrete must meet the design specifications. Many times it is more important to do good shotcrete for the temporary shoring just because it has a lower factor of safety and therefore less allowance for poor construction practices.
The most commonly used estimates for pH of concrete are 13 for plastic (fresh) concrete and about 10 for hardened concrete with a little age to it.
Shotcrete is pneumatically applied concrete. All surface prep work for concrete will be the same for shotcrete applications. Before a recommendation can be made, is this tank going to be painted on the outside or the inside? Second if this tank is to be painted on the inside, what will be put in it? The environment in which this tank is located also plays a key part in determining what type of paint or coating application. If this a tank that has been in operation, what was stored in it? Testing of the concrete in this case is important, in order to determine what method of surface prep would be needed to achieve a good coating bond.
The term “spacing factor” refers to the distance between air bubbles in hardened concrete. All concrete has some air bubbles, usually in the range of 1 or 2%, referred to as “entrapped air”. These bubbles provide no freeze/thaw protection. Where freeze/thaw protection is desired, air bubbles are intentionally introduced, or entrained, into the plastic concrete mixture. These microscopic bubbles protect the mortar portion of the concrete by providing space for water in the concrete to expand during the freezing process. If these bubbles were not available for this purpose, the expansion of the water would damage the mortar. An important characteristic of a good air-void system is the spacing factor. Bubbles need to be in close proximity so the water migrating through the concrete does not have to travel far to find a bubble in which the water can expand. Ideally the spacing factor will be less than 0.008 in. This analysis is performed on hardened concrete by a trained petrographer using test method ASTM C 457. There usually is some slight variance between petrographers evaluating the same concrete sample.
