Grotto Pool Project

When one of our core builders called us to announce their prospective client’s desire to completely redo their beach house on the Sound in Corolla, NC, they mentioned that a new concrete pool would be part of the project. Steve Daniels, of Renaissance Construction Company, Inc., had his designer, Paul Gilbertson, send us preliminary information on the prospective property and the client’s wish list for the backyard. To call it a transformation is a significant understatement

Barges, Golf Carts and Shotcrete

Bald Head Island, off the southern shores of North Carolina is a 6 mi2 (16 km2) island, accessed only by ferry, for guests, and by barge, for construction. It is steeped in history, playing a part in both the American Revolution and the Civil War. Feared by seamen, it is well protected by 30 mi (48 km) of shoals right off the cape into the Atlantic Ocean, known as the Frying Pan Shoals. North Carolina is famous for its barrier islands that

I am in the process of hiring a contractor to install a pool at my home. I have a long driveway, about 350 ft (100 m) and the pool will be constructed behind my house. The contractor wants to remove a substantial amount of plantings to allow the shotcrete truck to get closer to the pool area. How far can you reasonably pump shotcrete horizontally and what type/brand pump would be needed?

Shotcrete placement conveys concrete materials through a delivery line that ranges from 11⁄2 in. (38 mm) to 21⁄2 in. (64 mm) in diameter. A 2 in. (50 mm) diameter at the nozzle is most common. Wet-mix shotcrete pumps wet concrete through the line. Dry-mix conveys dry concrete materials through the line and adds water at the nozzle to make concrete. Using proper concrete materials, equipment and placing techniques both wet-mix and dry-mix should provide high strength, durable concrete for your pool. Wet-mix is more difficult to pump as it has more internal friction pushing the low-slump concrete through the line. Shotcrete contractors will try to minimize the delivery line length in wet-mix to make pumping easier and reduce the chance for plugs in the line. With proper planning, concrete mixture selection, and delivery line choices, wet-mix shotcrete can be pumped 500 ft (150 m) or more. The shotcrete contractor can increase the pumping distance by using steel pipe for most of the delivery line with rubber hose the last 50 to 75 ft (15 to 23 m), or using larger diameter hose or pipe and then reducing to the final size closer to the nozzle. If the shotcrete contractor is using dry-mix (often called Gunite) they should easily be able to reach over 500 ft as the delivery hose is mostly full of air conveying the dry concrete materials. This means you don’t have nearly the internal friction that would tend to cause plugging of the line, and thus allows for longer delivery lines.
Thus, if using wet-mix, check with the shotcrete contractor and see if they can make adjustments to their delivery lines to allow a greater pumping distance to accommodate your lot. If using dry-mix, they should have no problems running the hose to your back yard assuming they have enough hose.

Our shotcrete contractor started shooting our residential swimming pool on a Friday and stopped 1/3 of way through the process. They plan to restart and complete shooting the pool the following Monday. This site is in Houston and has been averaging 90+ °F (32 °C) average daily temperatures. Aside from soaking the existing pool structure during the hiatus and additional continuous watering through the 10 days after completion to let concrete cure, what steps do I and the contractor need to make to ensure a cold joint will not fail and leak in the future? I will be able to supervise the second shot. What can I do, or make sure the contractor does, to ensure the structural integrity and quality of my investment?

Wet curing of newly placed concrete is certainly important. Your 10-day cure sounds great. Properly placed shotcrete against a properly prepared construction joint will provide concrete that acts monolithically and will not be a “cold joint” as is common in cast concrete. There are three key factors for joint preparation:

  1. The joint must be roughened. This should be done when the crew finished for the day using a stiff broom or raking with a trowel.
  2. On the subsequent shoot the surface should be cleaned (usually using a high pressure, pressure washer).
  3. Before shooting bring the surface to a saturated surface dry (SSD) condition. SSD means the pores of the concrete have been filled with water but there is no running water on the surface.

Following these 3 steps are essential for creating a monolithic, watertight joint. Here’s a link to an article on why shotcrete doesn’t have cold joints: https://shotcrete.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/2014Spr_TechnicalTip.pdf

Quality shotcrete placement requires a well-designed concrete mixture, proper equipment, attention to the surface prep, proper placement techniques, and curing. One aspect that can help you ascertain the nozzleman’s expertise is to require they have a current American Concrete Institute Shotcrete Nozzleman Certification. You can verify an individual’s certification status at: https://www.concrete.org/certification/verifyacertification.aspx?d=Ask

 

 

I work for a Commercial pool builder. We are doing a Jr. Olympic pool (competition pool) 40 ft by 70 ft (12 m by 21 m) with a 20 ft by 10 ft (6 m by 3 m) swim out area with steps. I would rather have the entire pool shot with shotcrete. The office wants the floor poured first then shoot the walls the next day. Can you talk about any advantages or disadvantages to either? Normally we are in a remote location with no power or water. We’ve had issues with shotcrete cracking on the floors and I understand that can happen because of many factors but poured concrete can as well.

Casting the floor first is recommended. Note that rebound and trimmings from vertical wall placement are not fully consolidated concrete and must not be used as part of a structural concrete section. Thus, casting first allows:

  • No collection of rebound and trimmings from wall construction to get trapped below floor reinforcing steel.
  • Provides a stable surface to collect and remove rebound and trimmings.
  • Is generally faster placement and allows full consolidation of concrete throughout the floor thickness by immersion vibrators.
  • If using wet-mix shotcrete the shotcrete pump can serve as a line pump for pumping concrete into the floor thus requiring no extra equipment.
  • Allows proper joint preparation at the floor/wall joint to provide a watertight joint.

 

 

Our pool company just completed the shotcrete today and temperatures are expected to reach near freezing tonight. Should the shotcrete still cure properly? Should we be concerned?

You say near freezing, so we assume it did not reach freezing. Though the newly place concrete will not gain strength quickly it should not be damaged. As temperatures rise during the day the warmer temperatures should allow more strength gain. Concrete has a chemical reaction to build strength, that generates internal heat. If freezing weather was expected, we would recommend use of a protective blanket on the concrete surface to help hold the heat in and promote quicker strength gain. Generally, in concrete we like to see the concrete surface temperature at 50 °F (10 °C) or higher in cold weather to encourage strength gain.

 

 

Outstanding Pool & Recreational Project

Project Name:
Where Pour in Place Stops

Location:
Blowing Rock, NC

Shotcrete Contractor:
Revolution Gunite

Architect/Engineer:
Waterforge, Inc

Material Supplier/Manufacturer:
Revolution Gunite

Equipment Manufacturer:
Gunite Supply & Cementech

General Contractor:
Artisan Pools and MBI Builders

Project Owner:
Krista Biggard

Honorable Mention Project

Project Name:
Grotto Falls Lagoon

Location:
British Columbia, Canada

Shotcrete Contractor:
Oceanrock Art Ltd.

Architect/Engineer:
Kontur Geotechnical

Material Supplier/Manufacturer:
Cardinal Concrete

Equipment Manufacturer:
Putzmeister

General Contractor:
Oceanrock Art Ltd

I’m interested in any information you can provide about recommended expansion/contraction joint spacing for lazy river concrete flumes.

Shotcrete is a placement method for concrete. As the lazy river is a long concrete trough that is intended to be functionally watertight, the best guidance is ACI, 350-06 Code Requirements for Environmental Engineering Concrete Structures. As the predominate stresses in the horizontal direction result from shrinkage and temperature, Section 7.12.2.1 provides guidance on joint spacing based on the provided reinforcement ratio in the concrete section. The closer the movement joints, the less reinforcement required. Chapter 5 of ACI 350.4R-04, Design Considerations for Environmental Engineering Concrete Structures, has guidance on design of joints for water containing structures to help maintain water tightness.

Purlear Creek

In North Carolina, we are quite fond of our local swimming holes. Ask any Tar Heel, and they will assuredly regale you with tales of their childhood spent swinging wildly from ropes and jumping from or sliding down boulders. The swimming hole always held magic for us when we were small, with water that glowed with microscopic fool’s gold, and tiny fish that would nibble at our feet. It was a place where we could run, jump, and splash, all while nature was busily oiling the wheels of our young imaginations. It’s a scene that one North Carolinian couple wished to recreate for their grandchildren, right in their backyard.